Whos my good girl? Arthur, with Miss Grimshaw, rescue Tilly and successfully capture Anthony Foreman, who Tilly warns to stay away from her. Fighting breaks out, followed by shooting, and the gang make their escape. It is hinted by Dutch that Arthur may have had sex with Abigail before her relationship with John, as did the other members of the gang, when he is confronted by John at the bank in Blackwater in 1911. Eagle Flies was apprehensive and skeptical of him and believed he was nothing more than a hired hand who only worked for the highest bidder, and had no real care for the well-being of his people. Summary: Mary Beth want to confess her feelings for you, but she's nervous. And don't forget that if you did last mission for her, it was Arthur that refused to leave everything and be with her. She would call your name, asking what you thought about a specific part. His fair skin already had a tinge of gold from the past few days working in the sun. He tries to give Jack advice and, at the request of Abigail, asked if he wanted to go fishing with him. Arthur comforts him and tells him that he no longer has to worry about being alone again. Once she finally builds up the courage to do so she does it in her own way. It is generally believed that Mary-Beth had a crush on Arthur until, at least, she started developing feelings for Kieran, although this is unconfirmed. During the final train robbery Abigail is abducted by Agent Milton and taken to Van Horn, both Sadie and Arthur decide to rescue her. Johns last words to Arthur are we're brother's, which Arthur responds by saying I know, I know.. Despite this, the two work well together and Arthur can have pleasant conversations with him around camp. The two shared a hug as one last goodbye before departing. In the fight, Micah will say that he has been waiting a long time to kill Arthur, and will do so, if the player's honor is low. Its during a game that she tells Arthur that she learned how to play Dominoes, as well as the piano, when she was a young girl working at a bar. John took Arthurs words to heart of running and not looking back, as he used those words on Abigail and Jack before his own sacrifice. This was the last time they saw each other. Sean, the bastard thats dragged him along that evening, skips past him to sit in the booth behind her. Abigail is saddened when Arthur is forced to part ways with her and Sadie because he has to confront Micah. His strong, naked torso was littered with faint scars and a few strange tattoos. Arthur left a big impact on Sadie and she was grateful for his efforts to help her, as well as the Marston family. From the start of the story Dutch treats Arthur as his right-hand man, with Hosea being treated more like an equal partner. Ironically, it was John's quest for vengeance against Micah that set in motion a chain of events that would lead to his own downfall a few years later. A lot of people don't know, but Mary Beth and Kieran are most likely into each other. The first time he sees Abigail, shes sitting perched on a bright red vinyl booth seat dressed in cut-off shorts that are so short he can see the curve of her ass cheeks and wearing a cropped pink tee that proudly proclaims SAVE A HORSE, RIDE A COWBOY. Since this is an alternate time, there, of course, will be some changes to the story in order to align it with the time period. There, you got it. But when he looks in his son's eyes, he can only think to himself is, "Am I enough for him?". Arthur is aware of Micah's skills as a fighter and shooter, and Micah appears to respect Arthur for his shooting abilities in return, as well as saying that he finds it "fun" riding with Arthur. After many years. After getting the dynamite for an upcoming heist Arthur tells John that whatever happens during the robbery, and wherever Dutch goes, he will get him the money he needs and get out of this life. This gains both his and Dutch's admiration and respect, to the point where even Dutch reprimanded Bill for not respecting Sadie. My favorite trio UwUJohn, Diamonds & Rust Part II - Arthur x Reader (NSFW). Arthur aiding Eagle Flies gained his respect despite the fact he initially loathed Arthur and his kind, but nonetheless ends with Eagle Flies giving up his life for Arthur's. ", Dutch comments when going fishing with the two. As well as being friendly to each other around camp, Arthur can, when the gang is celebrating, dance with her. However, this might be because of her disappointment in how far Dutch has fallen rather than genuinely preferring Arthur, as anecdotes can be heard that Miss Grimshaw was rather close to Dutch before the events in the game. Arthur meets a woman with an affinity for cliff maids. Arthur returns Eagle Flies back to his to his father at the tribe's reservation, on the way Arthur expresses his regret for allowing him to get involved with Dutch, but Eagle Flies reassures him that all his decisions were his own. She can mention to him that she used to play the Harmonica but no longer has one, which allows Arthur to find one for her. Nonetheless, Arthur still respects him deeply because he keeps the camp fed, especially the women and children, and ultimately recognises the vital role he plays in keeping the gang going. Here she also admits to Arthur that, aside from her husband, Arthur is the best man she has ever known. Here, I remember you talking about it the other day, hed say, giving you a small, golden hair clip. She is also one of the members that can come up to Arthur for a chat, specifically concerning Karen and her drinking habits. While we've done our best to make the core functionality of this site accessible without javascript, it will work better with it enabled. tbh I woulda plowed the shit out of Karen if I was in the gang lmao. However, Arthur would reassure Lenny that he has friends and that he should not try to impress everyone in the gang because the people that matter (himself, Dutch and Hosea) are aware of the effort he puts in. He tells Strauss to get a job and gives him some money to leave, with Strauss doing so, never to be seen again. Arthur mentions Isaac when conversing with Rains Fall, telling him that the incident made him realize that he can't expect good things to happen to him with the life he led. Honestly that shit was god damn real as it gets if you've been there. Arthur is the longest serving member of the Van der Linde gang, excluding Hosea, with the Van der Linde gang starting with just Dutch, Hosea and Arthur. You sniggered, "Mary-Beth, I wouldn't dream of stealing your man." Mary-Beth, blushed. Regardless of the player's choices, Arthur and Micah will have one last fight, either a knife fight or a fistfight. Despite this, he agrees to work with Arthur for his people's sake. 2), Also it's up to you if you want this to be an & fic or a / fic. Vidla ped sebou chlapa, kter mluvil ke konm a respektoval eny, a ukzala na jeho mladho bratra, toho s nevymchanou hubou a vychovnm srovnatelnm s nosorocem, a ekla chci tohohle. For example, at some point during the Clemens Point chapter, Arthur may see her smoking alone at the camp's scout campfire. After the latter incident Trelawny chooses to stay with the gang for a while. They also pulled jobs together, such as robbing the bank in Valentine and stealing a wagon full of weapons and explosives from the Lemoyne Raiders at Shady Belle, it was because of this job that the gang knew of Shady Belle and could use it as their next camping spot. She is sixteen and he must be twice that. Sean interpreted this as proof that Arthur and the gang missed him with Arthur not wholeheartedly disputing this. Arthur protested continuing but John encourages him to keep pushing. Arthur later compliments Sean for his performance when destroying the fields. The two of you can often be found away from camp, hidden by a shade from a tree, you with your head in Mary-Beths lap, one of her hands in your hair, the other holding a book. At the same time, Arthur is haunted by memories of his past life, from 1883 to 1899. Was it for the last time, or was something else bound to happen? He would come up to you, his head hung low and say, Listen, Im sorry, I was out of line. He wouldnt dare to look up, simply waiting for your answer. This is quite frankly a place for me to just collect anything I write for this little rare-pair. At camp, Kieran never goes up to Arthur to engage in a conversation (with the exception of Jack's return party where he is drunk). At camp Arthur cannot really have pleasant interactions with Micah and no matter what the player does, every conversation devolves into sarcastic disputes between the two. They will ultimately succeed in this, however. However, Arthur promises to protect her and won't let anything happen, further showing how much he cares for Tilly. Arthur retorts that although he and Strauss are not good men, the people who Strauss was loan sharking to were. Maybe if Strauss had waited a little longer to call in that debt and given Dutch more time to unravel before him, he would have retired and died an old man with his true love beside him. When Jack was kidnapped by the Braithwaite family, and subsequently passed on to Angelo Bronte, Arthur would reassure John that everything would be okay. It turned out that Molly had lied and in fact rejected any attempt by the Pinkertons to recruit her, she lied about being a rat to simply get Dutch's attention. Throughout Arthur's last moments fighting Micah he continuously bragged that he has won, contradicting Micah's claims that he had lost, because he successfully saved John and his family. He later learned that they were robbed and killed for a meager amount of money. There are other times in the story when Arthur and John bicker, for example, when John gets Arthur's help to steal some sheep to sell off in Valentine the two can be heard arguing about Jack, with John complaining that Arthur took him fishing and with Arthur responding that John should be spending more time with his family, especially Jack. I also feel like whether they realize it or not, the rest of the gang tells Arthur she's no good for him because she's the one thing that could get him to give up the life. Summary:While snooping through Arthurs journal, Karen finds a portrait of a woman who draws her attention. You would attentively listen to the leader, Dutch was his name, and try to memorize the words he spoke. If you have been in a relationship you'll get it though. With many camp members expressing concern over this. Revealing that Arthur trusts her just as much as the other girls around the camp. Both Arthur and Charles were disgusted by Dutchs influence on Eagle Flies to get him to attack the U.S. Army which would compromise the safety on the Wapiti Tribe. Arthur mentions Eliza when conversing with Rains Fall, admitting that the incident caused him to believe he has no right to expect good things to happen to him because of the life he has led. She can also request Arthur to find her some Oregano herbs and in return will leave him some Miracle Tonic beside his tent. Arthur is filled with remorse over this, with Kieran having saved his life once but Arthur having been unable to save his. Arthur goes to check on the cabin only to be surprised and held at gun point, however, Kieran saves his life by shooting the O'Driscoll first. He would always remember the little things you mention, and would make sure to bring them to you when hes out. This page takes a look at Arthur's various relationship from the perspective of high honor and with Arthur agreeing to help all the characters he meets, as the game pushes you in this direction and is, as a result, the most likely experiences players will have when playing this game. However, their last encounter is Arthur delivering his mortally wounded son after he chose to attack Cornwall's oil factory under Dutch's manipulation to compel him to do so. Pearson can ask Arthur to find him a Naval Compass and in return will give him a bottle of Rum. I mean it is and it isn't, Location: Shady Belle (Red Dead Redemption), Chapter 4: Saint Denis (Red Dead Redemption 2), Chapter 3: Clemens Point (Red Dead Redemption 2), A Song of Ice and Fire - George R. R. Martin, Westerosi Characters | Characters From Westeros (A Song of Ice and Fire), Alternate Universe - Everyone Lives/Nobody Dies, apparently this ship hit me out of nowhere so here you go, Arthur reassuring Mary-Beth that her writing isn't silly, This fic is probably just going to be a collection of one-shots, my only excuse is that this fic should have already existed, From Tatters to Silk at the Touch of Your Hands, why are there so few works about these two they are literally made for each other, The Cowboys of LA: A Red Dead Redemption 1950's AU, Mother Superior Caldern (Red Dead Redemption). Arthur retorts that if he only cared about money he would be long gone. When she got caught up in an argument with Pearson, the camp's cook, whilst working for him, Arthur intervened and Sadie explained that she and her husband would share all the work, rather than being given only domestic, household work. a series of purely self indulgent things I want to see, there isnt enough variety in this fandom. Likelihood is that it'll all be happy ending stuff because I'm a happy ending sorta gal, not a sad, angsty sorta one. Arthur can also play Five Finger Fillet with her after the mission "Blessed are the Peacemakers". Mary Beth flushes and buries her head in her hands. When Lenny revealed his concern at being so far south in Lemoyne because of its history of racism, having been filled with slave plantation farms before the war, Arthur expressed his sympathy and acknowledged that it couldn't be easy for him. Arthur and Charles were very good friends. Depending on Arthur's honor level he will either get the dialogue option where Swanson reassures Arthur to keep fighting and to never change, and ultimately accept his flaws. He goes missing for a while when the gang moves to Shady Belle and his body soon turns up at camp on top of his horse with his decapitated head in his hands and his eyes poked out. The gang is in trouble, and as Arthur and Mary Beth aim to set out on their own one day, they must find a way to help those they love while eventually, finding escape. It mightve been fourth or maybe even fifth, but you couldnt tell. For most of1899, their relationship is strong and healthy, with Arthur having Dutchs full trust and respect and vice versa. Dutch, whilst at camp, will have spontaneous chats with Arthur, one of which can lead to Arthur offering to find Dutch a pipe after he mentions that he misses smoking one. Sadie builds up enough trust in Arthur that she asks for his help to hunt the last of the O'Driscoll Boys, bluntly telling Arthur that he is the only one out of all the fools in the gang she trusts. At one point Micah tells Arthur, when he needed his help, that he looked up to him, however he was very likely lying given the circumstances. When theyre done and hes tidied his clothes again, Dutch Van der Linde touches her shoulder with a smile and says, Wed be pleased to have your company, Miss Roberts., John's head isn't in the right place. Arthur Morgan did not intend to survive when he gave his hat to John Marston and stayed behind to gain his redemption. Arthur would write in his journal that Charles was a good man at heart. Sean backs down and tells Arthur that he loves him, perhaps genuinely so, because of his no nonsense approach. "Well, what do you think I came for, John?" Arthur is also willing to take part in Bill's plans, like robbing the bank in Valentine. Nonetheless, Arthur is slightly saddened for her death. Mary-Beth, he rumbles in reply, the depth of his voice thick with liquor and the cigarette hes nursing. Nonetheless, Uncle respects Arthur's authority and if he is told to do something he will do it, albeit reluctantly and with only the occasional backchat. Arthur has a brief yet friendly relationship with Joe, with the two talking about recent events. He emotionally tells Dutch that he "gave him all he had." When the camp is celebrating Sean's return she can ask Arthur for a dance. Despite this, Arthur keeps a picture of him next to his bed over two decades later and also wears his hat, hinting at some measure of fondness. Before leaving Arthur tells both of them that they are good women and one of the best. In reality, however, Arthur was thankful for Kieran saving his life. When the gang starts to fall apart Arthur can tell Uncle that he should leave before its too late. This proved to be very useful later in the story when Arthur tries to find there whereabouts of the gang after his return from Guarma. The gang was able to barter with Bronte for the return of Jack, much to Abigail's relief who emotionally thanked Arthur and the others. Stuck in Colter with no stables to buy a horse from, Arthur decides to go out and get you one, but not just any one, a White Arabian. Howdy, my fellow outlaws! From a certain perspective, the void that was left behind by Arthur removing Dutch from his sense of admiration is filled by Rains Fall. Finally, a comment about her I can relate to. Abigail Roberts.Arthur Morgan.John Marston.Three people.Two who have been in each others' lives for what seems like forever.One who came in and changed everything.Highs and lows that seemed lower than possible.No matter what though, no matter what will happen in all three of their lives,they'll be there for each other. Hosea often calls for Arthur's backing when he is having disputes with Dutch, and even with some fellow gang members such as Bill. Summary: Its been three years since thatfateful night. Arthur then dies and, depending on his honor level, it will either be from Micah killing him or peacefully succumbing to his tuberculosis. Arthur, with Charles, then rescues Eagles Flies from Fort Wallace, much to Rains Fall's gratitude. After giving her the pocket mirror Molly will start leaving him a cigar at his tent. At the same time, Arthur is haunted by memories of his past life, from 1883 to 1899. Jack narratesand reimaginesseveral important moments in his early childhood. However, Kieran gives up details on a possible whereabouts of Colm O'Driscoll and Dutch decides that he should go along with Arthur, John and Bill to show them where. Believing that he owes it to Arthur to help John and his family, who Arthur gave up his life for. Micah was initially aggressive towards her but Dutch and Arthur were able to calm her and take her back to camp. After Arthur, Dutch, Javier, Bill and Micah return from Guarma, Arthur is surprised to discover that it was Sadie who rounded up the gang members after the failed bank job in Saint Denis and got them to safety and have since been waiting for them to return. If you've never been a relationship where you both love one another but just can't make it work because you aren't quite compatible then you won't really get it. Arthur writes in one entry, sometime near his death, that he hopes John uses his brain better and that the luck that has eluded him will continue to help John instead. It was your third week with this group of people. Miss Grimshaw is one of the camp members Arthur can play Poker with. John refuses and doesnt want to leave him behind but Arthur tells him that neither of them will make it out as Arthur is being slowed down by his illness and knows that he is eventually going to die. He's taken to bed and the Van der lin women begin to reat him. Arthur can have positive conversations with her, and at one point both of them discuss about how much they love to write, with Mary-Beth preferring to write stories and Arthur preferring to write his experiences in his journal, they both bond slightly over this shared interest. Arthur, along with Dutch and Micah, rescued Sadie early on in the story when the O'Driscoll Boys ransacked her home and killed her husband. Whilst at camp Arthur treats Jack with great care and affection when talking to him. How will they survive when all hope seems lost? If anything could have saved Arthur from his fate, it was Mary Linton. "I wish I were cross-eyed so I can see you twice.". In some minor missions Rains Fall shows his respect for Arthur and expresses his belief that he is a good man after they ride past a pack wolves and Arthur scares them off instead of killing them, and when they arrive at a camp site with ancient artifacts, only for them to have been stolen, Arthur sneaks into a camp to retrieve them without killing anyone, once more earning Rains Fall's respect and praise. Well, oftentimes I have one character say what Im thinkin before the other comes and comforts them. she blushed, realizing what she was saying, and that she couldnt just outright tell Arthur that the comforting she spoke of really meant fucking, and that the character which did so was always him. Arthur interacts with Mary-Beth, where the two share anecdotes of their past, before Miss Grimshaw comes up to Arthur to tell him that Tilly has gone missing. This is also doable in the final chapter of the story, but this time it is just a chance encounter rather than for celebration. Mary-Beth Gaskill is a supporting character featured in Red Dead Redemption 2. Tilly is also very kind to Arthur, frequently expressing concern for him as his health begins to deteriorate and wishing he'd take better care of himself. Arthur loved his son and remembered Isaac fondly as being "such a good kid." Dutch also shows clear trust in Arthur and complete confidence in his protege's numerous abilities. Navigating the strangeness of waking up in a different century soon takes a spot on the back burner when a ghost from the past begins to threaten the ranch. John comments that Arthur has always had his back to which Arthur responds, "Maybe not always." Mary and Arthur reunite when she sends him a letter to come meet her outside of Valentine, and asking for his help in getting her brother away from Chelonia, and later again in Saint Denis, this time with her father. He arrived on the Bluebell Railway on 17th May 1960, after the railway's founder Bernard Holden MBE helped to save the line for preservation. The experience hardened him and made him realise that he doesn't deserve the kind of happiness that his now dead family once gave him because of the life he leads. Arthur is 36-37. Arthur barges in and immediately knocks him out. Basically a what-if, what if John never came back after running out on Abigail and Jack? Abigail begged Arthur, as well as Dutch and John, to rescue her son when he was kidnapped by the Braithwaites. please <3The title for this fanfic (like almost all my other works) is from a song; this time its Accused of Love by Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers. I ended up loving how they concluded Marys plot line in the end credits. He then asks Karen if she is okay, with her telling him she is fine. John shook his head, Hes the strangest man., Abigail smirked, Ye have to admit, the crops were better than ever last year. Arthur and Molly rarely interacted. He becomes more friendly to him and now refers to him as "O'Driscoll" in jest rather than out of scorn. With Arthur having become greatly disillusioned with Dutch, andnow realizing that he hasbecome a shadow of his former self, or possibly the man he has always been who merely uses others to further his own desires, he decides to help John, Abigail and Jack escape the gang and be free from all this trouble. Now she was Out, she could be who she wanted to be and Leslie Dupont was who she had wanted to be: an author who was not afraid and wrote with her heart. Arthur openly dislikes Micah because of his negative influence on the gang, and Dutch specifically. Whilst escaping Arthur falls to the ground after a steam pipe bursts in his face and is held at knife point, Dutch decides to leave Arthurfor dead even though he could easily have saved him. He tells both her and Abigail that they are the best women he has ever known and bids an emotional farewell. He further demonstrates his hostility by calling Arthur a turncoat after Bill goes at Abigail and Uncle. Arthur was Leopold Strauss' strongman when he loaned out money to desperate people. One chat in particular leads to Arthur telling Uncle that he is dying but will use the time he has left to help others make it out safely, with Uncle simply commenting that he is a good man. Suddenly, John's light-hearted gaze darkened as his stance became somewhat domineering. Under the assumption that Jack had lost John, Arthur ran off with Sadie to rescue Abigail to prevent Jack from becoming an orphan. The incident devastated Arthur and he never truly coped with the loss. Feeling sorry for her, Arthur teaches her how to hunt and skin and survive in the wilderness. Mary-Beth sits on the chair beside where Arthur has sprawled himself in the grass. Im really into this fandom right now (after finishing both RDR1 and RDR2 (currently on my second play through)) so I wanted to start writing for it. Some stories will be one-shots, others might have a sequel. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. While we've done our best to make the core functionality of this site accessible without javascript, it will work better with it enabled. Please consider turning it on! Arthur simply retorts that he is aware he doesn't have much competition, but is clearly touched by her comment. You know, as an example of sorts., Or: Arthur reads Mary-Beth's journal and things only get better from there. Good Things Come in Three (Arthur x Reader x Sadie) (NSFW), Just the Three of Us (Arthur x Reader x Charles), Killing Me Softly With Her Song - Arthur x Reader, The Girl from the North Country - Arthur x Reader (NSFW), every day I dont get to kiss arthur morgan is a day very badly spent, I wish I were cross-eyed so I can see you twice., What? Just the mention of her portrait puts Arthur years in the past, right to the very night the two shared. His only notable encounter is having an argument with Sadie when she refuses to cut the vegetables for him, with Arthur intervening before a fight breaks out. Should the player accept, Arthur will attack the ranch. Miss Grimshaw killing Molly divides the camp with everyone under the impression that she was telling the truth, some claimed it was justified as Molly knew the rules whilst others were sympathetic towards her as she only did what she did because she loved Dutch.